%PDF-1.3 1 0 obj << /Kids [ 3 0 R 4 0 R 5 0 R 6 0 R 7 0 R 8 0 R 9 0 R 10 0 R ] /Type /Pages /Count 8 >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Title (A Comparison of Human and Automated Face Verification Accuracy on Unconstrained Image Sets) /Producer (PyPDF2) /Author (Austin Blanton\054 Kristen C\056 Allen\054 Timothy Miller\054 Nathan D\056 Kalka\054 Anil K\056 Jain) /Subject (2016 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition Workshops) >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 12 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /x8 13 0 R /x6 16 0 R /x12 19 0 R /x10 22 0 R >> /ExtGState << /s9 25 0 R /s11 28 0 R /a0 << /CA 1 /ca 1 >> /R23 31 0 R /s5 32 0 R /s7 35 0 R >> /Font << /F2 38 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 43 0 R /R38 44 0 R /R32 48 0 R /R24 52 0 R /R30 56 0 R /R26 59 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 67 0 R 68 0 R 69 0 R 70 0 R 71 0 R 72 0 R 73 0 R 74 0 R 75 0 R 76 0 R 77 0 R 78 0 R 79 0 R 80 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 4 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 81 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R78 82 0 R /R79 83 0 R /R76 84 0 R /R77 85 0 R /R83 86 0 R /R81 87 0 R /R80 88 0 R /R87 89 0 R /R86 90 0 R /R85 91 0 R /R84 92 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R23 31 0 R >> /Font << /F2 93 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 94 0 R /R24 52 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /Text /ImageC /ImageB /PDF /ImageI ] /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 95 0 R 96 0 R 97 0 R 98 0 R 99 0 R 100 0 R 101 0 R 102 0 R 103 0 R 104 0 R 105 0 R 106 0 R 107 0 R 108 0 R 109 0 R 110 0 R 111 0 R 112 0 R 113 0 R 114 0 R 115 0 R 116 0 R 117 0 R 118 0 R 119 0 R 120 0 R 121 0 R 122 0 R 123 0 R 124 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 5 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 125 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R103 126 0 R /R102 127 0 R /R105 128 0 R /R104 129 0 R /R107 130 0 R /R106 131 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R23 31 0 R >> /Font << /R108 132 0 R /R110 135 0 R /F2 138 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 139 0 R /R32 48 0 R /R24 52 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /Text /ImageC /ImageB /PDF /ImageI ] /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 140 0 R 141 0 R 142 0 R 143 0 R 144 0 R 145 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 6 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 146 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R248 147 0 R /R249 150 0 R /R246 151 0 R /R247 152 0 R /R244 153 0 R /R245 154 0 R /R242 155 0 R /R243 156 0 R /R240 157 0 R /R241 158 0 R /R163 159 0 R /R162 160 0 R /R161 161 0 R /R160 162 0 R /R167 163 0 R /R166 164 0 R /R165 165 0 R /R164 166 0 R /R169 167 0 R /R168 168 0 R /R264 169 0 R /R265 170 0 R /R178 171 0 R /R179 172 0 R /R174 173 0 R /R175 174 0 R /R176 175 0 R /R177 176 0 R /R170 177 0 R /R171 178 0 R /R172 179 0 R /R173 180 0 R /R181 181 0 R /R180 182 0 R /R266 183 0 R /R267 184 0 R /R260 185 0 R /R261 186 0 R /R262 187 0 R /R263 188 0 R /R189 189 0 R /R188 190 0 R /R268 191 0 R /R190 192 0 R /R191 193 0 R /R215 194 0 R /R197 195 0 R /R194 196 0 R /R195 197 0 R /R128 198 0 R /R192 199 0 R /R210 200 0 R /R213 201 0 R /R212 202 0 R /R196 203 0 R /R214 204 0 R /R217 205 0 R /R216 206 0 R /R219 207 0 R /R218 208 0 R /R198 209 0 R /R199 210 0 R /R202 211 0 R /R203 212 0 R /R200 213 0 R /R201 214 0 R /R206 215 0 R /R207 216 0 R /R204 217 0 R /R205 218 0 R /R208 219 0 R /R209 220 0 R /R183 221 0 R /R127 222 0 R /R126 223 0 R /R125 224 0 R /R124 225 0 R /R185 226 0 R /R129 227 0 R /R184 228 0 R /R187 229 0 R /R186 230 0 R /R239 231 0 R /R238 232 0 R /R237 233 0 R /R236 234 0 R /R235 235 0 R /R234 236 0 R /R233 237 0 R /R232 238 0 R /R231 239 0 R /R230 240 0 R /R133 241 0 R /R134 242 0 R /R135 243 0 R /R136 244 0 R /R137 245 0 R /R138 246 0 R /R139 247 0 R /R182 248 0 R /R228 249 0 R /R229 250 0 R /R220 251 0 R /R221 252 0 R /R222 253 0 R /R223 254 0 R /R224 255 0 R /R225 256 0 R /R226 257 0 R /R227 258 0 R /R145 259 0 R /R144 260 0 R /R147 261 0 R /R146 262 0 R /R141 263 0 R /R140 264 0 R /R143 265 0 R /R142 266 0 R /R149 267 0 R /R148 268 0 R /R269 269 0 R /R211 271 0 R /R259 272 0 R /R258 273 0 R /R255 274 0 R /R254 275 0 R /R257 276 0 R /R256 277 0 R /R251 278 0 R /R250 279 0 R /R253 280 0 R /R252 281 0 R /R156 282 0 R /R157 283 0 R /R154 284 0 R /R155 285 0 R /R152 286 0 R /R153 287 0 R /R150 288 0 R /R151 289 0 R /R193 270 0 R /R158 290 0 R /R159 291 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R131 148 0 R /R23 31 0 R >> /Font << /R108 132 0 R /R110 135 0 R /F2 293 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 294 0 R /R24 52 0 R /R26 59 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /Text /ImageC /ImageB /PDF /ImageI ] /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> >> /Group 295 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 296 0 R 297 0 R 298 0 R 299 0 R 300 0 R 301 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 7 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 302 0 R /Resources << /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R23 31 0 R >> /Font << /F2 303 0 R /R108 132 0 R /R289 304 0 R /R287 308 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 312 0 R /R285 313 0 R /R24 52 0 R /R26 59 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 317 0 R 318 0 R 319 0 R 320 0 R 321 0 R 322 0 R 323 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 8 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 324 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R319 325 0 R /R312 329 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R131 148 0 R /R23 31 0 R /R297 330 0 R /R304 331 0 R >> /Font << /R298 332 0 R /R317 336 0 R /R315 340 0 R /R110 135 0 R /R313 344 0 R /F2 348 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 349 0 R /R302 350 0 R /R300 354 0 R /R307 358 0 R /R320 362 0 R /R305 366 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R /R310 327 0 R >> >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 370 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 9 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 371 0 R /Resources << /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R23 31 0 R >> /Font << /R349 372 0 R /R347 376 0 R /R351 380 0 R /R345 384 0 R /R353 388 0 R /R343 392 0 R /R341 396 0 R /F2 400 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 401 0 R /R339 402 0 R /R337 406 0 R /R32 48 0 R /R24 52 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 410 0 R 411 0 R 412 0 R 413 0 R 414 0 R 415 0 R 416 0 R 417 0 R 418 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 10 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /TrimBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Contents 419 0 R /Resources << /ColorSpace << /R37 63 0 R /R35 65 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R23 31 0 R >> /Font << /F2 420 0 R /R28 39 0 R /F1 421 0 R /R32 48 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 422 0 R 423 0 R 424 0 R 425 0 R 426 0 R 427 0 R 428 0 R 429 0 R 430 0 R 431 0 R 432 0 R 433 0 R 434 0 R 435 0 R 436 0 R 437 0 R 438 0 R 439 0 R 440 0 R 441 0 R 442 0 R 443 0 R 444 0 R ] /Type /Page /BleedBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] >> endobj 11 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 1 0 R >> endobj 12 0 obj << /Length 19196 >> stream q q q 0.10000 0 0 0.10000 0 0 cm /R23 gs 0 g q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R24 14.34620 Tf 1 0 0 1 77.51410 675.06700 Tm [ (A) -250.00200 (Comparison) -250.00400 (of) -250.01200 (Human) -249.99000 (and) -249.99100 (A) 50.00170 (utomated) -250.01000 (F) 24.98890 (ace) -250.01000 (V) 99.99310 (eri\336cation) -250.01200 (Accuracy) -250.00200 (on) ] TJ 140.00400 -17.93320 Td [ (Unconstrained) -249.99600 (Image) -250.00500 (Sets) ] TJ /R26 9.96260 Tf 160.18800 5.20703 Td (\041) Tj /R28 11.95520 Tf -278 -43.06480 Td [ (Austin) -250.01000 (Blanton) ] TJ 20.42500 -13.94730 Td (Noblis) Tj /R30 8.96640 Tf -29.78670 -13.94800 Td (imaus10\100gmail\056com) Tj /R28 11.95520 Tf 146.39900 27.89530 Td [ (Kristen) -249.98700 (C\056) -249.98700 (Allen) ] TJ 23.40820 -13.94730 Td (Noblis) Tj /R30 8.96640 Tf -48.61600 -13.94800 Td (kristen\056allen\100noblis\056org) Tj /R28 11.95520 Tf 199.90400 27.89530 Td [ (T) 34.98980 (im) -250.01400 (Miller) ] TJ 10.25080 -13.94730 Td (Noblis) Tj /R30 8.96640 Tf -51.30590 -13.94800 Td (timothy\056miller\100noblis\056org) Tj /R28 11.95520 Tf -196.10300 -19.92500 Td [ (Nathan) -249.98500 (D\056) -250.01000 (Kalka) ] TJ 24.39410 -13.94770 Td (Noblis) Tj /R30 8.96640 Tf -45.92620 -13.94800 Td (nathan\056kalka\100noblis\056org) Tj /R28 11.95520 Tf 197.84500 27.89570 Td [ (Anil) -250.01400 (K\056) -250.01000 (Jain) ] TJ -33.76720 -13.94770 Td [ (Michig) 4.99096 (an) -250.00800 (State) -250.00200 (Uni) 24.99570 (v) 14.98510 (ersity) ] TJ /R30 8.96640 Tf 19.78520 -13.94800 Td (jain\100cse\056msu\056edu) Tj /R24 11.95520 Tf -190.61700 -41.04610 Td (Abstract) Tj /R32 9.96260 Tf -83.92770 -23.91020 Td [ (A) 20 (utomatic) -333.00700 (face) -333 (r) 37.01960 (eco) 9.99466 (gnition) -333 (tec) 15.01590 (hnolo) 9.98608 (gies) -332.98900 (have) -333 (seen) -333 (sig\055) ] TJ -11.95510 -11.95510 Td [ (ni\336cant) -395.98200 (impr) 44.99370 (o) 10.00320 (vements) -396.00400 (in) -396 (performance) -395.98300 (due) -396.00700 (to) -396 (a) -396.00700 (combina\055) ] TJ 11.95470 TL T* [ (tion) -256.99100 (of) -257.98400 (advances) -257.00200 (in) -257.98400 (deep) -257.01500 (learning) -257.02000 (and) -257.98100 (availability) -257.00100 (of) -257.98400 (lar) 36.99140 (g) 10.00320 (er) ] TJ 11.95630 TL T* [ (datasets) -489.01800 (for) -488.99800 (tr) 14.99140 (aining) -488.00200 (deep) -489.01500 (networks\056) -1027.01000 (Since) -489.00900 (r) 37.01830 (eco) 9.99588 (gnizing) ] TJ 11.95470 TL T* [ (faces) -378.00600 (is) -378.00200 (a) -378.01000 (task) -378.00200 (that) -377.99100 (humans) -377.98600 (ar) 36.98520 (e) -377.98100 (belie) 14.98890 (ved) -378.01800 (to) -378.00300 (be) -378.01500 (very) -377.98300 (good) ] TJ T* [ (at\054) -245.00300 (it) -243.98400 (is) -245.00400 (only) -243.98600 (natur) 15.00610 (al) -243.98600 (to) -243.98600 (compar) 36.99380 (e) -244.00300 (the) -243.99100 (r) 37.01960 (elative) -245.00300 (performance) -244.00800 (of) ] TJ T* [ (automated) -374.99700 (face) -376.01200 (r) 37.01960 (eco) 9.99466 (gnition) -374.99400 (and) -374.98200 (humans) -375.00600 (when) -375.99600 (pr) 44.98510 (ocessing) ] TJ T* [ (fully) -240.01600 (unconstr) 15.01340 (ained) -241 (facial) -240.01100 (ima) 10.01300 (g) 10.00320 (ery) 55.00800 (\056) -307.00500 (In) -239.99800 (this) -240.99400 (work\054) -242.01600 (we) -241.00900 (e) 19.99180 (xpand) ] TJ 11.95590 TL T* [ (on) -304.99800 (pr) 36.98520 (e) 15.01280 (vious) -304.98900 (studies) -305.01500 (of) -304.99600 (the) -305 (r) 37.01960 (eco) 9.99466 (gnition) -305.00500 (accur) 14.98520 (acy) -305.99100 (of) -304.99600 (humans) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (and) -338.00700 (automated) -339.00300 (s) 0.98635 (ystems) -338.98900 (by) -337.98200 (performing) -338.01700 (se) 15.01960 (ver) 15.01470 (al) -338.01000 (no) 10.00810 (vel) -339.00500 (anal\055) ] TJ T* [ (yses) -295.98600 (utilizing) -296.01100 (unconstr) 15.01340 (ained) -296.01100 (face) -295.98600 (ima) 10.01300 (g) 10.00320 (ery) 55.00800 (\056) -448.98100 (W) 91.98710 (e) -295.99500 (e) 19.99180 (xamine) -296.01700 (the) ] TJ T* [ (impact) -359.01500 (on) -358.98900 (performance) -359.98900 (when) -359.02000 (human) -359.01500 (r) 37.01830 (eco) 9.99588 (gnizer) 9.98363 (s) -358.99400 (ar) 36.98650 (e) -359.98400 (pr) 36.98650 (e\055) ] TJ T* [ (sented) -395.99800 (with) -397 (varying) -395.99300 (amounts) -396.99600 (of) -396 (ima) 10.01300 (g) 10.00320 (ery) -396.01500 (per) -396.98500 (subject\054) -433.00100 (im\055) ] TJ T* [ (mutable) -383.00700 (attrib) 19.99540 (utes) -382.98100 (suc) 14.98520 (h) -382.01000 (as) -382.98400 (g) 10.00320 (ender) 111.00800 (\054) -416.00700 (and) -383.01900 (cir) 36.98400 (cumstantial) -382.98000 (at\055) ] TJ 11.95630 TL T* [ (trib) 19.98320 (utes) -300.99500 (suc) 14.98460 (h) -299.98400 (as) -300.99800 (occlusion\054) -313.01200 (illumination\054) -313.01200 (and) -300.99400 (pose) 14.99010 (\056) -461.99900 (Results) ] TJ 11.95470 TL T* [ (indicate) -434.01800 (that) -433.98200 (humans) -434.01600 (gr) 36.98520 (eatly) -433.99500 (outperform) -434.00100 (state) -433.98400 (o) -1.01454 (f) -433.99900 (the) -433.99900 (art) ] TJ T* [ (automated) -333.00400 (face) -333 (r) 37.01960 (eco) 9.99466 (gnition) -333 (algorithms) -332.98600 (on) -334.01300 (the) -332.99600 (c) 15.01220 (hallenging) ] TJ T* [ (IJB\055A) -250 (dataset\056) ] TJ /R24 11.95520 Tf 35.00900 TL T* [ (1\056) -249.99000 (Intr) 18.01460 (oduction) ] TJ /R28 9.96260 Tf 11.95510 -18.92890 Td [ (Human) -351.01900 (capabilities) -351.00500 (ha) 19.99790 (v) 14.98280 (e) -351.00500 (serv) 14.98160 (ed) -351 (as) -352.01800 (the) -350.99300 (\322gold) -350.98300 (standard\323) ] TJ -11.95510 -11.95510 Td [ (for) -345.98300 (f) 9.99527 (acial) -347 (recognition) -345.98600 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 142.80400 209.47300 Tm (19) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 152.76700 209.47300 Tm [ (\135\056) -600.01900 (Barring) -346.00100 (kno) 24.99090 (wledge) -346.98900 (of) -346.01800 (the) -346.99400 (cir) 19.99670 (\055) ] TJ -102.65500 -11.95510 Td [ (cumstances) -193.98200 (of) -194.00600 (capture\054) -204.98200 (human) -193.98400 (comparison) -194.01200 (of) -194.00400 (f) 9.99588 (acial) -194.00400 (imagery) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (is) -372.00300 (the) -372.98900 (best) -372.00200 (w) 10 (ay) -372.01500 (to) -372.00400 (v) 14.98280 (erify) -372.99500 (or) -372.01500 (dif) 24.98480 (ferentiate) -372.01400 (f) 9.99588 (aces) -371.98400 (within) -373.00100 (im\055) ] TJ 11.95590 TL T* [ (agery) -323.00700 (or) -323.00300 (video\054) -340.98100 (and) -322.99900 (has) -322.99800 (been) -323.00400 (successfully) -323.01200 (used) -322.99300 (in) -322.99300 (the) -322.99800 (cre\055) ] TJ ET Q 3.98000 w 0 G 501.12100 1661.31000 m 1446.11000 1661.31000 l S q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R38 5.97760 Tf 1 0 0 1 60.14100 159.52900 Tm (\041) Tj /R28 7.97010 Tf 4.31680 -2.81289 Td [ (This) -459.02300 (research) -458.99500 (is) -458.98600 (based) -459.00800 (upon) -458.99500 (w) 10.01210 (ork) -459 (supported) -458.97900 (by) -459.01800 (the) -458.99100 (Of) 24.97740 (\336ce) -459.01200 (of) -458.98800 (the) ] TJ -14.34570 -9.46406 Td [ (Director) -529.01300 (of) -529.02400 (National) -529.00400 (Intelligence) -528.99300 (\050ODNI\051\054) -528.98800 (Intelligence) -528.99400 (Adv) 24.98350 (anced) -528.98500 (Re\055) ] TJ 9.46484 TL T* [ (search) -548.02400 (Projects) -547.01800 (Acti) 24.98350 (vity) -548.00600 (\050IARP) 92.01410 (A\051\054) -548.02000 (via) -547.01400 (FBI) -548.00600 (Contract) -546.99100 (\043) -548.00800 (GS10F0189T) 91.98500 (\055) ] TJ 9.46406 TL T* [ (DJF151200G0005824\056) -661.98800 (The) -366.97800 (vie) 24.99730 (ws) -368.01400 (and) -367.01700 (conclusions) -366.99100 (contained) -367.99500 (herein) -366.98400 (are) ] TJ 9.46484 TL T* [ (those) -382.00900 (of) -381.99000 (the) -383.02300 (authors) -382.00500 (and) -382.01400 (should) -381.99400 (not) -382.01300 (be) -382.98000 (interpre) 1.01698 (ted) -383.02300 (as) -381.99100 (necessarily) -382.01600 (repre\055) ] TJ 9.46406 TL T* [ (senting) -296.98000 (the) -297.00800 (of) 25 (\336cial) -297.01300 (policies) -297.98100 (or) -297.00500 (endorsements\054) -308.99300 (either) -296.97500 (e) 15.00360 (xpressed) -297.02400 (or) -297.00500 (implied\054) ] TJ 9.46523 TL T* [ (of) -311.02200 (ODNI\054) -311.02100 (IARP) 91.99730 (A\054) -311.01800 (or) -311.02300 (the) -310.97500 (U\056S\056) -311.00900 (Go) 14.99900 (v) 14.98370 (ernment\056) -493.98700 (The) -311.00700 (U\056S\056) -311.01000 (Go) 14.99750 (v) 14.98520 (ernment) -311.02000 (is) -311.02000 (au\055) ] TJ 9.46406 TL T* [ (thorized) -364.98100 (to) -364.99300 (reproduce) -364.98700 (and) -365.00700 (distrib) 20.00730 (ute) -364.98600 (reprints) -365.00900 (for) -365.01500 (Go) 14.99750 (v) 14.98520 (ernmental) -365.01500 (purposes) ] TJ 9.46484 TL T* [ (notwithstanding) -249.99400 (an) 14.99130 (y) -250.02000 (cop) 9.97840 (yright) -250.01400 (annotation) -249.98800 (thereon\056) ] TJ /R28 9.96260 Tf 258.75000 421.51400 Td [ (ation) -258.99600 (of) -259.99300 (testing) -258.98100 (databases) -259.98400 (at) -259.01100 (scale) -259.99600 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 447.77100 502.51400 Tm (8) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 452.75200 502.51400 Tm [ (\135\056) -337.98300 (As) -259.00600 (automated) -260.00600 (recog\055) ] TJ -143.89000 -11.95510 Td [ (nition) -246 (approaches) -247.01300 (human) -246.01500 (le) 25.02030 (v) 14.98280 (els) -247.00800 (of) -245.99800 (accurac) 14.99750 (y) 65.01370 (\054) -247.01300 (the) -247.00800 (kno) 24.99090 (wledge) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (that) -368.98300 (humans) -367.98800 (can) -369 (recognize) -368.99700 (f) 9.99343 (aces) -369.00200 (across) -368.01200 (v) 24.98110 (ariations) -369.01200 (in) -368.98700 (age\054) ] TJ T* [ (pose\054) -457.98700 (illumination) -416.01600 (and) -416.00400 (e) 15.01220 (xpression) -416.01900 (\050A\055PIE\051) -416 (requires) -416 (addi\055) ] TJ T* [ (tional) -200.01800 (impro) 15.00480 (v) 14.98280 (ement) -201.01100 (at) -200.00300 (such) -199.99600 (comparisons\056) -293.98500 (The) -200 (common) -200.99100 (goal) ] TJ 11.95630 TL T* [ (for) -307.99000 (computer) -308.00500 (vision) -307.99300 (systems) -307.00800 (is) -308.01200 (to) -308.01700 (match) -308.01200 (or) -307.98800 (surpass) -308.00700 (human) ] TJ 11.95470 TL T* [ (accurac) 14.99750 (y) -374.99100 (at) -376.01300 (the) -374.98900 (same) -374.98600 (task) -376 (with) -375.01100 (objecti) 25 (vity) -375.01100 (and) -376.01100 (ef) 25.00560 (\336cienc) 14.99260 (y) 65.01370 (\056) ] TJ T* [ (In) -239.01600 (the) -239.01200 (conte) 14.98520 (xt) -239.00700 (of) -237.99700 (automated) -238.99000 (f) 9.99343 (ace) -238.99400 (recognition) -238.98500 (on) -239.00900 (constrained) ] TJ T* [ (images\054) -310.00200 (this) -298.98400 (g) 4.98446 (ap) -297.99000 (has) -297.98200 (been) -297.99000 (bridged\056) -454.99800 (Recent) -298.01400 (publications) -299 (on) ] TJ T* [ (f) 9.99588 (aces) -377.98300 (in) -378.98300 (the) -378.00800 (wild) -379.01300 (benchmar) 0.99003 (ks) -378.98600 (such) -378.00600 (as) -378.99600 (LFW) -377.99600 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 496.06900 394.91800 Tm (7) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 501.05000 394.91800 Tm [ (\135) -378.02000 (and) -378.99100 (YTF) ] TJ -192.18800 -11.95510 Td (\133) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 312.18000 382.96300 Tm (21) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 322.14200 382.96300 Tm [ (\135) -250 (ha) 19.99670 (v) 14.98280 (e) -250.00200 (seen) -249.99500 (this) -250.01200 (g) 4.98446 (ap) -249.99700 (narro) 25.01540 (w) -249.99300 (as) -249.99700 (well) -249.98300 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 467.01800 382.96300 Tm (3) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 472 382.96300 Tm (\135\056) Tj -151.18200 -13.49690 Td [ (In) -398.01000 (this) -397.00700 (w) 10 (ork\054) -435.01600 (we) -396.99500 (seek) -398.01200 (to) -398.00200 (e) 15.01220 (xpand) -397.01700 (on) -398.00200 (pre) 25.01050 (vious) -397.98300 (compar) 20.00650 (\055) ] TJ -11.95510 -11.95510 Td [ (isons) -341.99200 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 336.07000 357.51100 Tm (2) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 341.05100 357.51100 Tm (\054) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 346.94900 357.51100 Tm (5) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 351.93000 357.51100 Tm (\054) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 357.82800 357.51100 Tm (12) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 367.79100 357.51100 Tm (\054) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 373.68900 357.51100 Tm (17) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 383.65100 357.51100 Tm (\054) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 389.53900 357.51100 Tm (13) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 399.50200 357.51100 Tm (\054) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 405.40000 357.51100 Tm (16) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 415.36200 357.51100 Tm [ (\135) -341.98700 (of) -342.02100 (the) -342.01200 (recognition) -341.98700 (accurac) 14.99750 (y) -342.01600 (of) ] TJ -106.50000 -11.95590 Td [ (humans) -305.01800 (and) -305.00300 (automated) -305.01800 (systems) -305.00800 (by) -304.99800 (performing) -306.00300 (three) -305.00800 (no) 14.98770 (v) 14.98280 (el) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (analyses\072) -333.01800 (\050i\051) -261.01500 (measuring) -262.00500 (and) -261.01000 (comparing) -262.00500 (accurac) 14.99750 (y) -261.01000 (on) -261.98600 (uncon\055) ] TJ T* [ (strained) -324.00500 (f) 9.99588 (ace) -323.01700 (imagery) 64.98670 (\054) -342.01900 (\050ii\051) -324.01500 (measuring) -323.01500 (accurac) 14.99750 (y) -324.01900 (when) -324.01500 (com\055) ] TJ T* [ (paring) -215.00800 (image) -213.98900 (sets) -215.00800 (\050as) -214.00600 (opposed) -214.99800 (to) -215.01300 (single) -214.01800 (image) -215.00800 (comparisons\051) ] TJ T* [ (and) -305.00300 (\050iii\051) -306.01300 (e) 15.01220 (xamining) -305.00500 (the) -306.02000 (ef) 25.00560 (fect) -305.01300 (of) -305.98800 (immutable) -304.99800 (attrib) 20.01630 (utes) -306.01300 (such) ] TJ 11.95630 TL T* [ (as) -430.98400 (gender) -430.00400 (and) -430.98200 (circumstantial) -430.98200 (attrib) 20.01630 (utes) -429.99200 (such) -431.01600 (as) -430.98700 (illumina\055) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (tion\054) -399.98500 (occlusion) -371.00400 (and) -370.01200 (pose\056) -671.01100 (The) -370.01200 (research) -369.99200 (is) -370.00200 (enabled) -370.00700 (by) -370.98700 (the) ] TJ T* [ (recently) -334.01500 (released) -333.98600 (IJB\055A) -334.00800 (dataset) -334.00800 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 442.23100 261.86900 Tm (8) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 447.21300 261.86900 Tm [ (\135\054) -355 (which) -334.00800 (contains) -333.99800 (media) ] TJ -138.35000 -11.95510 Td [ (in) -294.99700 (the) -295.98200 (wild) -294.98800 (images) -294.98800 (and) -295.98500 (videos) -294.98500 (from) -295 (500) -296.01400 (subjects\054) -305.99800 (with) -296.00500 (full) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (pose) -340.00900 (v) 24.98110 (ariation\056) -579.99900 (This) -340 (is) -340.00900 (notably) -341.01200 (dif) 24.98600 (f) 1.01454 (erent) -341.00200 (from) -340.01200 (the) -340.01200 (seminal) ] TJ T* [ (LFW) -328.00400 (dataset\054) -348.00600 (and) -329 (other) -328.01400 (media) -328.98900 (in) -328.01400 (the) -328.01400 (wild) -328.97900 (datasets\054) -348 (which) ] TJ 11.95590 TL T* [ (were) -228.99100 (\336ltered) -228.99900 (to) -229.98900 (only) -228.99900 (contain) -229.00100 (f) 9.99343 (aces) -228.98600 (detectable) -229.01100 (by) -229.99100 (a) -228.98600 (commod\055) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (ity) -250.01700 (f) 9.99588 (ace) -250.01000 (detector) -249.99000 (trained) -249.98500 (on) -249.98800 (frontal) -249.98300 (f) 9.99343 (aces\056) ] TJ 11.95510 -13.49690 Td [ (Through) -290.98600 (these) -291 (analyses\054) -300.98900 (we) -291.01000 (seek) -291.01000 (to) -291 (understand) -290.98600 (whether) ] TJ -11.95510 -11.95510 Td [ (or) -241.99600 (not) -241.00100 (human) -242.01600 (accurac) 14.99750 (y) -241.99400 (de) 15.01710 (grades) -241.01400 (in) -241.98900 (a) -242.00400 (similar) -240.98400 (manner) -241.98900 (as) -241.99900 (ma\055) ] TJ T* [ (chines) -239.98400 (when) -239.99200 (the) -239.01200 (quality) -240.00700 (of) -240 (a) -240.00400 (f) 9.99343 (ace) -238.99400 (sample) -240.01900 (de) 15.01710 (grades) -239.99400 (\050e\056g\056\054) -241.99400 (e) 15.01220 (x\055) ] TJ T* [ (treme) -352.01200 (pose\054) -378.98100 (adv) 14.98280 (erse) -351.98500 (illumination\054) -377.98100 (occlusion\051\056) -617.98500 (It) -352.01500 (is) -352.98500 (kno) 24.99090 (wn) ] TJ T* [ (that) -312.01200 (algorithms) -312.01900 (perform) -311 (w) 10.00320 (orse) -311.98200 (on) -312.01700 (fully) -312.00700 (unconstrained) -311.99200 (f) 9.99343 (ace) ] TJ T* [ (images) -286.98900 (\133) ] TJ ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 343.26300 128.82100 Tm (8) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 348.24400 128.82100 Tm (\054) Tj ET Q /R35 cs 0 1 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 353.59400 128.82100 Tm (20) Tj ET Q /R37 cs 0 scn q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R28 9.96260 Tf 1 0 0 1 363.55700 128.82100 Tm [ (\135) -287.99400 (b) 20.00160 (ut\054) -296.01400 (to) -286.99900 (our) -287.00600 (kno) 24.99090 (wledge\054) -296.99500 (such) -287.00100 (a) -287.01600 (study) -286.98200 (has) -287.98600 (not) ] TJ -54.69450 -11.95630 Td [ (yet) -267.98700 (been) -267.01200 (performed) -267.98500 (for) -267.99700 (human) -268.00900 (recognition\056) -362.99800 (Because) -267.99000 (IJB\055A) ] TJ 11.95470 TL T* [ (is) -201.99300 (the) -201.99800 (\336rst) -203 (unconstrained) -202.01000 (f) 9.99343 (ace) -202.02000 (dataset) -201.99100 (unbiased) -201.98100 (by) -203.01500 (detectable) ] TJ T* [ (f) 9.99588 (aces\054) -327.98900 (it) -312.99200 (is) -312.99400 (important) -313.00400 (to) -312.99400 (establish) -311.99200 (a) -313.01200 (human) -312.98200 (baseline) -312.98700 (for) -313.00700 (au\055) ] TJ T* [ (tomated) -371.00900 (methods) -369.98000 (to) -370.98500 (aspire) -370.99200 (to) -370.98700 (match) -370.00200 (and) -370.99200 (surpass) -371.01700 (humans\056) ] TJ ET Q Q Q q q 1 1 1 rg /a0 gs 48.40600 786.42200 515.18800 -52.69900 re f q /s5 gs /x6 Do Q q /s7 gs /x8 Do Q q /s9 gs /x10 Do Q q /s11 gs /x12 Do Q Q Q Q q 1 0 0 1 0 0 cm BT /F1 12 Tf 14.40000 TL ET 1 1 1 rg n 270 32 72 14 re f* 0.50000 0.50000 0.50000 rg BT /F2 9 Tf 10.80000 TL ET BT 1 0 0 1 299.25000 35 Tm (161) Tj T* ET Q endstream endobj 13 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Resources << /ExtGState << /a0 << /CA 1 /ca 1 >> >> /XObject << /x18 14 0 R >> >> /Length 28 /Group << /Type /Group /S /Transparency /CS /DeviceRGB /I true >> /BBox [ 78 746 96 765 ] /Type /XObject /Subtype /Form >> stream x+O4PH/VЯ0Pp 0 endstream endobj 14 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /Resources 15 0 R /Length 107 /Type /XObject /BBox [ 78 746 96 765 ] /Subtype /Form >> stream xe AC̬wʠ =p,?]%+H-
Jc "82w8VSnGW;"
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/ExtGState <<
/a0 <<
/CA 1
/ca 1
>>
>>
>>
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Resources <<
/ExtGState <<
/a0 <<
/CA 1
/ca 1
>>
>>
/XObject <<
/x15 17 0 R
>>
>>
/Length 28
/Group <<
/Type /Group
/S /Transparency
/CS /DeviceRGB
/I true
>>
/BBox [ 67 752 84 775 ]
/Type /XObject
/Subtype /Form
>>
stream
x+O4PH/VЯ04Up
0
endstream
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Resources 18 0 R
/Length 228
/Type /XObject
/BBox [ 67 752 84 775 ]
/Subtype /Form
>>
stream
xeQKn!s ?FPav6R٪TS.
b];15YyR
{7QL.\:Rv/x9l+L7h%1!}i/AI(kz"U&,YO![R hg{3}4/GyYF:!w}Gn+'xJcO9i뽼_-:`
endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/ExtGState <<
/a0 <<
/CA 1
/ca 1
>>
>>
>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Resources <<
/ExtGState <<
/a0 <<
/CA 1
/ca 1
>>
>>
/XObject <<
/x24 20 0 R
>>
>>
/Length 28
/Group <<
/Type /Group
/S /Transparency
/CS /DeviceRGB
/I true
>>
/BBox [ 112 751 500 772 ]
/Type /XObject
/Subtype /Form
>>
stream
x+O4PH/VЯ02Qp
0
endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/Filter /FlateDecode
/Resources 21 0 R
/Length 56490
/Type /XObject
/BBox [ 112 751 500 772 ]
/Subtype /Form
>>
stream
xtIJ5*|^~x?P9)<<ҥ+kh4}/?>]漿վ]Z Ǭ57W'b~?Kwk6:>rAニxeG1k-/LfߗA̺(egk5>
=KO1{Vux}Ol|_s؟|*>5=k|*a5x}On :97~1s7rX {|>IQQo6|'\#x_ڽC}M7(췀(N
سW#^Ň}|zblnB'\o=r;$s:z-
V3+έ昵 WD/nl ;q"3Pg휅\3C`k7760c9-Cȸ