%PDF-1.3 1 0 obj << /Kids [ 3 0 R 4 0 R 5 0 R 6 0 R 7 0 R 8 0 R 9 0 R 10 0 R 11 0 R ] /Type /Pages /Count 9 >> endobj 2 0 obj << /Title (Discovering Causal Signals in Images) /Producer (PyPDF2) /Author (David Lopez\055Paz\054 Robert Nishihara\054 Soumith Chintala\054 Bernhard Scholkopf\054 Leon Bottou) /Subject (2017 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition) >> endobj 3 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 13 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R31 14 0 R /R42 17 0 R /R41 18 0 R /R40 19 0 R /R36 30 0 R /R37 31 0 R /R34 32 0 R /R35 33 0 R /x8 46 0 R /R30 36 0 R /R25 34 0 R /x6 49 0 R /R29 25 0 R /R28 26 0 R /R27 27 0 R /R38 28 0 R /R39 29 0 R /R21 20 0 R /R19 21 0 R /R23 22 0 R /R22 23 0 R /x12 52 0 R /R24 35 0 R /x10 55 0 R /R26 24 0 R >> /ExtGState << /s9 58 0 R /s11 61 0 R /R8 64 0 R /a0 << /CA 1 /ca 1 >> /R18 15 0 R /s5 65 0 R /s7 68 0 R >> /Font << /R9 71 0 R /F1 75 0 R /F2 76 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R13 77 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R32 41 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /Group 45 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ ] >> endobj 4 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 84 0 R /Resources << /ExtGState << /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /F2 85 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R9 71 0 R /F1 90 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 95 0 R 96 0 R 97 0 R 98 0 R 99 0 R 100 0 R 101 0 R 102 0 R 103 0 R 104 0 R 105 0 R 106 0 R 107 0 R 108 0 R 109 0 R 110 0 R ] >> endobj 5 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 111 0 R /Resources << /ExtGState << /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /R9 71 0 R /F1 112 0 R /R116 113 0 R /R114 116 0 R /F2 120 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 121 0 R 122 0 R 123 0 R 124 0 R 125 0 R 126 0 R 127 0 R 128 0 R 129 0 R 130 0 R 131 0 R 132 0 R 133 0 R 134 0 R 135 0 R 136 0 R 137 0 R 138 0 R 139 0 R 140 0 R 141 0 R 142 0 R 143 0 R 144 0 R 145 0 R 146 0 R 147 0 R 148 0 R 149 0 R 150 0 R 151 0 R 152 0 R 153 0 R 154 0 R 155 0 R 156 0 R ] >> endobj 6 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Contents 157 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R677 158 0 R /R676 159 0 R /R675 160 0 R /R674 161 0 R /R673 162 0 R /R672 163 0 R /R671 164 0 R /R670 165 0 R /R679 166 0 R /R678 167 0 R /R178 168 0 R /R179 169 0 R /R174 170 0 R /R175 171 0 R /R176 172 0 R /R177 173 0 R /R170 174 0 R /R171 175 0 R /R172 176 0 R /R173 177 0 R /R718 178 0 R /R719 179 0 R /R710 180 0 R /R711 181 0 R /R712 182 0 R /R713 183 0 R /R714 184 0 R /R715 185 0 R /R716 186 0 R /R717 187 0 R /R404 188 0 R /R405 189 0 R /R406 190 0 R /R407 191 0 R /R400 192 0 R /R401 193 0 R /R569 194 0 R /R568 195 0 R /R567 196 0 R /R566 197 0 R /R565 198 0 R /R564 199 0 R /R563 200 0 R /R409 201 0 R /R561 202 0 R /R560 203 0 R /R769 204 0 R /R768 205 0 R /R819 206 0 R /R818 207 0 R /R817 208 0 R /R816 209 0 R /R815 210 0 R /R814 211 0 R /R813 212 0 R /R812 213 0 R /R811 214 0 R /R810 215 0 R /R880 216 0 R /R881 217 0 R /R882 218 0 R /R968 219 0 R /R884 220 0 R /R885 221 0 R /R886 222 0 R /R887 223 0 R /R963 224 0 R /R962 225 0 R /R961 226 0 R /R960 227 0 R /R967 228 0 R /R966 229 0 R /R965 230 0 R /R964 231 0 R /R585 232 0 R /R584 233 0 R /R587 234 0 R /R586 235 0 R /R581 236 0 R /R580 237 0 R /R583 238 0 R /R582 239 0 R /R589 240 0 R /R588 241 0 R /R1030 242 0 R /R1048 243 0 R /R1049 244 0 R /R1046 245 0 R /R1047 246 0 R /R1044 247 0 R /R1045 248 0 R /R1042 249 0 R /R1043 250 0 R /R1040 251 0 R /R1041 252 0 R /R518 253 0 R /R519 254 0 R /R1132 255 0 R /R1133 256 0 R /R1039 257 0 R /R1038 258 0 R /R1136 259 0 R /R1137 260 0 R /R1134 261 0 R /R1135 262 0 R /R1033 263 0 R /R1032 264 0 R /R1031 265 0 R /R1139 266 0 R /R1037 267 0 R /R1036 268 0 R /R1035 269 0 R /R1034 270 0 R /R361 271 0 R /R360 272 0 R /R363 273 0 R /R362 274 0 R /R365 275 0 R /R364 276 0 R /R367 277 0 R /R366 278 0 R /R369 279 0 R /R368 280 0 R /R418 281 0 R /R248 282 0 R /R249 283 0 R /R246 284 0 R /R247 285 0 R /R244 286 0 R /R245 287 0 R /R242 288 0 R /R243 289 0 R /R240 290 0 R /R241 291 0 R /R1157 292 0 R /R951 293 0 R /R578 294 0 R /R470 295 0 R /R661 296 0 R /R662 297 0 R /R663 298 0 R /R664 299 0 R /R665 300 0 R /R666 301 0 R /R667 302 0 R /R668 303 0 R /R669 304 0 R /R615 305 0 R /R614 306 0 R /R617 307 0 R /R616 308 0 R /R611 309 0 R /R610 310 0 R /R613 311 0 R /R612 312 0 R /R619 313 0 R /R618 314 0 R /R776 315 0 R /R777 316 0 R /R774 317 0 R /R775 318 0 R /R772 319 0 R /R773 320 0 R /R471 321 0 R /R579 322 0 R /R473 323 0 R /R472 324 0 R /R475 325 0 R /R474 326 0 R /R477 327 0 R /R476 328 0 R /R570 329 0 R /R571 330 0 R /R572 331 0 R /R573 332 0 R /R574 333 0 R /R575 334 0 R /R576 335 0 R /R577 336 0 R /R808 337 0 R /R809 338 0 R /R778 339 0 R /R779 340 0 R /R800 341 0 R /R801 342 0 R /R802 343 0 R /R803 344 0 R /R804 345 0 R /R805 346 0 R /R770 347 0 R /R807 348 0 R /R989 349 0 R /R988 350 0 R /R981 351 0 R /R980 352 0 R /R983 353 0 R /R982 354 0 R /R985 355 0 R /R984 356 0 R /R987 357 0 R /R986 358 0 R /R974 359 0 R /R975 360 0 R /R976 361 0 R /R977 362 0 R /R970 363 0 R /R971 364 0 R /R972 365 0 R /R973 366 0 R /R505 367 0 R /R504 368 0 R /R507 369 0 R /R506 370 0 R /R978 371 0 R /R979 372 0 R /R503 373 0 R /R502 374 0 R /R879 375 0 R /R878 376 0 R /R875 377 0 R /R874 378 0 R /R877 379 0 R /R876 380 0 R /R871 381 0 R /R870 382 0 R /R873 383 0 R /R872 384 0 R /R419 385 0 R /R596 386 0 R /R597 387 0 R /R594 388 0 R /R595 389 0 R /R592 390 0 R /R593 391 0 R /R590 392 0 R /R591 393 0 R /R598 394 0 R /R599 395 0 R /R1194 396 0 R /R1059 425 0 R /R1058 426 0 R /R1192 410 0 R /R1193 415 0 R /R1055 427 0 R /R1054 428 0 R /R1057 429 0 R /R1056 430 0 R /R1051 431 0 R /R1050 432 0 R /R1053 433 0 R /R1052 434 0 R /R922 435 0 R /R1121 436 0 R /R1120 437 0 R /R1123 438 0 R /R1122 439 0 R /R1125 440 0 R /R1124 441 0 R /R1127 442 0 R /R1126 443 0 R /R1129 444 0 R /R1128 445 0 R /R372 446 0 R /R373 447 0 R /R370 448 0 R /R371 449 0 R /R376 450 0 R /R377 451 0 R /R374 452 0 R /R375 453 0 R /R378 454 0 R /R379 455 0 R /R279 456 0 R /R278 457 0 R /R946 458 0 R /R273 459 0 R /R272 460 0 R /R271 461 0 R /R270 462 0 R /R277 463 0 R /R276 464 0 R /R275 465 0 R /R274 466 0 R /R181 467 0 R /R180 468 0 R /R183 469 0 R /R182 470 0 R /R185 471 0 R /R184 472 0 R /R187 473 0 R /R186 474 0 R /R189 475 0 R /R188 476 0 R /R500 477 0 R /R350 478 0 R /R351 479 0 R /R441 480 0 R /R699 481 0 R /R698 482 0 R /R695 483 0 R /R694 484 0 R /R697 485 0 R /R696 486 0 R /R691 487 0 R /R690 488 0 R /R693 489 0 R /R692 490 0 R /R169 491 0 R /R168 492 0 R /R402 493 0 R /R403 494 0 R /R606 495 0 R /R607 496 0 R /R604 497 0 R /R605 498 0 R /R602 499 0 R /R603 500 0 R /R600 501 0 R /R601 502 0 R /R408 503 0 R /R608 504 0 R /R609 505 0 R /R462 506 0 R /R463 507 0 R /R460 508 0 R /R461 509 0 R /R466 510 0 R /R467 511 0 R /R464 512 0 R /R465 513 0 R /R468 514 0 R /R469 515 0 R /R749 516 0 R /R748 517 0 R /R743 518 0 R /R742 519 0 R /R741 520 0 R /R740 521 0 R /R747 522 0 R /R746 523 0 R /R745 524 0 R /R744 525 0 R /R765 526 0 R /R764 527 0 R /R767 528 0 R /R1068 529 0 R /R998 530 0 R /R999 531 0 R /R1069 532 0 R /R992 533 0 R /R761 534 0 R /R990 535 0 R /R991 536 0 R /R996 537 0 R /R997 538 0 R /R994 539 0 R /R995 540 0 R /R763 541 0 R /R762 542 0 R /R901 543 0 R /R900 544 0 R /R903 545 0 R /R902 546 0 R /R905 547 0 R /R904 548 0 R /R907 549 0 R /R906 550 0 R /R516 551 0 R /R517 552 0 R /R514 553 0 R /R515 554 0 R /R512 555 0 R /R513 556 0 R /R510 557 0 R /R511 558 0 R /R868 559 0 R /R869 560 0 R /R866 561 0 R /R867 562 0 R /R864 563 0 R /R865 564 0 R /R862 565 0 R /R863 566 0 R /R860 567 0 R /R861 568 0 R /R1063 569 0 R /R486 570 0 R /R509 571 0 R /R508 572 0 R /R806 573 0 R /R1183 397 0 R /R1182 398 0 R /R1181 399 0 R /R1180 400 0 R /R1187 401 0 R /R1186 411 0 R /R1185 403 0 R /R1184 413 0 R /R1060 574 0 R /R1061 575 0 R /R1062 576 0 R /R1188 414 0 R /R1064 577 0 R /R1065 578 0 R /R1066 579 0 R /R1067 580 0 R /R562 581 0 R /R1118 582 0 R /R1119 583 0 R /R1114 584 0 R /R1115 585 0 R /R1116 586 0 R /R1117 587 0 R /R1110 588 0 R /R1111 589 0 R /R1112 590 0 R /R1113 591 0 R /R264 592 0 R /R265 593 0 R /R266 594 0 R /R267 595 0 R /R260 596 0 R /R261 597 0 R /R349 598 0 R /R348 599 0 R /R347 600 0 R /R346 601 0 R /R345 602 0 R /R344 603 0 R /R343 604 0 R /R342 605 0 R /R341 606 0 R /R340 607 0 R /R192 608 0 R /R193 609 0 R /R190 610 0 R /R191 611 0 R /R196 612 0 R /R197 613 0 R /R194 614 0 R /R195 615 0 R /R501 616 0 R /R198 617 0 R /R199 618 0 R /R299 619 0 R /R298 620 0 R /R291 621 0 R /R290 622 0 R /R293 623 0 R /R292 624 0 R /R295 625 0 R /R294 626 0 R /R297 627 0 R /R296 628 0 R /R688 629 0 R /R689 630 0 R /R686 631 0 R /R687 632 0 R /R684 633 0 R /R685 634 0 R /R682 635 0 R /R683 636 0 R /R680 637 0 R /R681 638 0 R /R771 639 0 R /R262 640 0 R /R263 641 0 R /R969 642 0 R /R883 643 0 R /R268 644 0 R /R269 645 0 R /R888 646 0 R /R889 647 0 R /R633 648 0 R /R632 649 0 R /R631 650 0 R /R630 651 0 R /R637 652 0 R /R636 653 0 R /R635 654 0 R /R634 655 0 R /R639 656 0 R /R638 657 0 R /R754 658 0 R /R755 659 0 R /R756 660 0 R /R757 661 0 R /R750 662 0 R /R751 663 0 R /R459 664 0 R /R458 665 0 R /R457 666 0 R /R456 667 0 R /R455 668 0 R /R656 669 0 R /R453 917 0 R /R759 951 0 R /R451 919 0 R /R450 920 0 R /R822 952 0 R /R823 953 0 R /R820 954 0 R /R793 955 0 R /R826 956 0 R /R827 957 0 R /R912 958 0 R /R913 959 0 R /R529 941 0 R /R528 942 0 R /R916 960 0 R /R796 961 0 R /R914 962 0 R /R915 963 0 R /R523 943 0 R /R522 944 0 R /R521 945 0 R /R919 964 0 R /R527 947 0 R /R526 948 0 R /R525 949 0 R /R524 950 0 R /R798 965 0 R /R859 966 0 R /R858 967 0 R /R799 968 0 R /R853 969 0 R /R852 970 0 R /R851 971 0 R /R850 972 0 R /R857 973 0 R /R411 889 0 R /R855 974 0 R /R854 975 0 R /R410 890 0 R /R1190 409 0 R /R1191 402 0 R /R909 976 0 R /R908 977 0 R /R1178 412 0 R /R1179 404 0 R /R1176 405 0 R /R1177 406 0 R /R1174 407 0 R /R1175 408 0 R /R1172 978 0 R /R1173 979 0 R /R1170 980 0 R /R1171 981 0 R /R1109 983 0 R /R1108 984 0 R /R1103 985 0 R /R1102 986 0 R /R1101 987 0 R /R1100 988 0 R /R1107 989 0 R /R1106 990 0 R /R1105 991 0 R /R1104 992 0 R /R211 852 0 R /R210 817 0 R /R213 672 0 R /R212 673 0 R /R215 674 0 R /R214 675 0 R /R217 676 0 R /R216 677 0 R /R219 895 0 R /R218 896 0 R /R352 678 0 R /R353 679 0 R /R354 680 0 R /R355 681 0 R /R356 682 0 R /R357 683 0 R /R1088 994 0 R /R1089 995 0 R /R1082 996 0 R /R1083 997 0 R /R1080 998 0 R /R1081 999 0 R /R1086 1000 0 R /R1087 1001 0 R /R1084 1002 0 R /R1085 1003 0 R /R1189 416 0 R /R1077 1006 0 R /R1076 1007 0 R /R1075 1008 0 R /R1074 1009 0 R /R1073 1010 0 R /R1072 1011 0 R /R1071 1012 0 R /R1070 1013 0 R /R1079 1014 0 R /R1078 1015 0 R /R329 684 0 R /R328 685 0 R /R766 1004 0 R /R325 686 0 R /R324 687 0 R /R327 688 0 R /R326 689 0 R /R321 690 0 R /R320 691 0 R /R323 692 0 R /R322 693 0 R /R288 694 0 R /R289 695 0 R /R282 696 0 R /R283 697 0 R /R280 698 0 R /R281 699 0 R /R286 700 0 R /R287 701 0 R /R284 702 0 R /R285 703 0 R /R760 1005 0 R /R839 1051 0 R /R145 704 0 R /R144 705 0 R /R147 706 0 R /R146 707 0 R /R141 708 0 R /R140 709 0 R /R143 710 0 R /R142 711 0 R /R624 712 0 R /R625 713 0 R /R626 714 0 R /R627 715 0 R /R620 796 0 R /R621 729 0 R /R622 718 0 R /R623 719 0 R /R838 1052 0 R /R488 897 0 R /R489 898 0 R /R891 1017 0 R /R890 1178 0 R /R721 1018 0 R /R720 1019 0 R /R723 1020 0 R /R722 1021 0 R /R725 1022 0 R /R724 1023 0 R /R727 1024 0 R /R726 1025 0 R /R440 722 0 R /R628 758 0 R /R442 723 0 R /R443 724 0 R /R444 725 0 R /R445 726 0 R /R446 727 0 R /R629 759 0 R /R487 901 0 R /R480 902 0 R /R481 903 0 R /R482 904 0 R /R898 1186 0 R /R149 716 0 R /R148 717 0 R /R534 730 0 R /R535 731 0 R /R536 732 0 R /R537 733 0 R /R530 734 0 R /R531 735 0 R /R532 831 0 R /R533 818 0 R /R538 819 0 R /R539 820 0 R /R844 1028 0 R /R845 1029 0 R /R846 1030 0 R /R847 1031 0 R /R840 1032 0 R /R841 1033 0 R /R929 1126 0 R /R928 1127 0 R /R927 1036 0 R /R926 1037 0 R /R925 1038 0 R /R924 1039 0 R /R923 1131 0 R /R430 743 0 R /R921 1041 0 R /R920 1042 0 R /R431 742 0 R /R831 982 0 R /R830 993 0 R /R785 1102 0 R /R784 1046 0 R /R783 1047 0 R /R782 1048 0 R /R428 807 0 R /R836 1107 0 R /R930 1108 0 R /R931 1109 0 R /R424 811 0 R /R425 812 0 R /R422 813 0 R /R423 814 0 R /R936 1114 0 R /R937 1115 0 R /R899 1055 0 R /R1169 1056 0 R /R1168 1057 0 R /R1165 1058 0 R /R1164 1059 0 R /R1167 1060 0 R /R1166 1061 0 R /R1161 1062 0 R /R1160 1063 0 R /R1163 1064 0 R /R1162 1065 0 R /R448 720 0 R /R484 899 0 R /R449 721 0 R /R202 749 0 R /R203 750 0 R /R200 751 0 R /R201 752 0 R /R206 753 0 R /R207 754 0 R /R204 755 0 R /R205 756 0 R /R208 757 0 R /R209 746 0 R /R797 1167 0 R /R1099 1066 0 R /R729 1026 0 R /R728 1027 0 R /R1091 1068 0 R /R1090 1069 0 R /R1093 1070 0 R /R1092 1071 0 R /R1095 1072 0 R /R1094 1073 0 R /R1097 1074 0 R /R1096 1075 0 R /R1002 1076 0 R /R1003 1077 0 R /R1000 1078 0 R /R1001 1079 0 R /R1006 1080 0 R /R1007 1081 0 R /R1004 1082 0 R /R1005 1083 0 R /R1008 1084 0 R /R447 728 0 R /R338 760 0 R /R339 761 0 R /R336 762 0 R /R337 763 0 R /R334 764 0 R /R335 765 0 R /R332 766 0 R /R333 767 0 R /R330 768 0 R /R331 769 0 R /R485 900 0 R /R383 770 0 R /R382 771 0 R /R381 772 0 R /R380 773 0 R /R387 774 0 R /R386 775 0 R /R385 776 0 R /R384 777 0 R /R389 778 0 R /R388 779 0 R /R1130 1086 0 R /R1131 1087 0 R /R1138 1088 0 R /R156 780 0 R /R157 781 0 R /R154 782 0 R /R155 783 0 R /R152 784 0 R /R153 785 0 R /R150 786 0 R /R151 787 0 R /R651 788 0 R /R650 789 0 R /R653 790 0 R /R652 791 0 R /R655 792 0 R /R654 793 0 R /R158 794 0 R /R159 795 0 R /R478 748 0 R /R732 1089 0 R /R733 1090 0 R /R730 1091 0 R /R731 1092 0 R /R736 1093 0 R /R737 1094 0 R /R734 1095 0 R /R735 1096 0 R /R738 1097 0 R /R739 1098 0 R /R497 825 0 R /R496 826 0 R /R541 797 0 R /R540 798 0 R /R543 799 0 R /R542 800 0 R /R545 801 0 R /R544 802 0 R /R547 803 0 R /R546 804 0 R /R549 805 0 R /R548 806 0 R /R499 829 0 R /R938 1100 0 R /R939 1101 0 R /R833 1045 0 R /R832 1103 0 R /R835 1104 0 R /R834 1105 0 R /R837 1106 0 R /R429 808 0 R /R426 809 0 R /R427 810 0 R /R932 1110 0 R /R933 1111 0 R /R934 1112 0 R /R935 1113 0 R /R420 815 0 R /R421 816 0 R /R787 1043 0 R /R493 821 0 R /R492 822 0 R /R491 823 0 R /R490 824 0 R /R949 1117 0 R /R948 1118 0 R /R495 827 0 R /R494 828 0 R /R945 1119 0 R /R944 1120 0 R /R947 1121 0 R /R498 830 0 R /R941 1122 0 R /R940 1123 0 R /R943 1124 0 R /R942 1125 0 R /R786 1044 0 R /R439 736 0 R /R438 737 0 R /R842 1034 0 R /R843 1035 0 R /R435 738 0 R /R434 739 0 R /R437 740 0 R /R1158 1128 0 R /R1159 1129 0 R /R436 741 0 R /R1150 1130 0 R /R848 1040 0 R /R1152 1132 0 R /R1153 1133 0 R /R1154 1134 0 R /R1155 1135 0 R /R1156 1136 0 R /R849 1116 0 R /R433 744 0 R /R432 745 0 R /R479 747 0 R /R239 832 0 R /R238 833 0 R /R237 834 0 R /R236 835 0 R /R235 836 0 R /R234 837 0 R /R358 670 0 R /R232 839 0 R /R231 840 0 R /R230 841 0 R /R1098 1067 0 R /R781 1049 0 R /R359 671 0 R /R1011 1137 0 R /R1010 1138 0 R /R1013 1139 0 R /R1012 1140 0 R /R1015 1141 0 R /R1014 1142 0 R /R1017 1143 0 R /R1016 1144 0 R /R1019 1145 0 R /R1018 1146 0 R /R780 1050 0 R /R752 1187 0 R /R753 1188 0 R /R309 842 0 R /R308 843 0 R /R303 844 0 R /R302 845 0 R /R301 846 0 R /R300 847 0 R /R307 848 0 R /R306 849 0 R /R305 850 0 R /R304 851 0 R /R454 916 0 R /R758 1189 0 R /R452 918 0 R /R398 853 0 R /R399 854 0 R /R394 855 0 R /R395 856 0 R /R396 857 0 R /R397 858 0 R /R390 859 0 R /R391 860 0 R /R392 861 0 R /R393 862 0 R /R163 863 0 R /R162 864 0 R /R161 865 0 R /R160 866 0 R /R167 867 0 R /R166 868 0 R /R165 869 0 R /R164 870 0 R /R640 871 0 R /R641 872 0 R /R646 873 0 R /R647 874 0 R /R644 875 0 R /R645 876 0 R /R1151 1147 0 R /R1143 1194 0 R /R1142 1195 0 R /R993 1150 0 R /R789 1151 0 R /R709 1152 0 R /R708 1153 0 R /R707 1154 0 R /R706 1155 0 R /R705 1156 0 R /R704 1157 0 R /R703 1158 0 R /R702 1159 0 R /R701 1160 0 R /R700 1161 0 R /R788 1054 0 R /R1149 1204 0 R /R1148 1205 0 R /R552 877 0 R /R553 878 0 R /R550 879 0 R /R551 880 0 R /R556 881 0 R /R557 882 0 R /R554 883 0 R /R555 884 0 R /R558 885 0 R /R559 886 0 R /R790 1162 0 R /R791 1163 0 R /R792 1164 0 R /R821 1206 0 R /R794 1165 0 R /R795 1166 0 R /R824 1209 0 R /R825 1211 0 R /R413 887 0 R /R412 888 0 R /R828 1168 0 R /R829 1169 0 R /R417 891 0 R /R416 892 0 R /R415 893 0 R /R414 894 0 R /R897 1171 0 R /R896 1172 0 R /R895 1173 0 R /R894 1174 0 R /R893 1175 0 R /R892 1176 0 R /R958 1177 0 R /R959 1016 0 R /R956 1179 0 R /R957 1180 0 R /R954 1181 0 R /R955 1182 0 R /R952 1183 0 R /R953 1184 0 R /R950 1185 0 R /R483 905 0 R /R1009 1085 0 R /R910 1207 0 R /R911 1208 0 R /R917 1170 0 R /R918 1210 0 R /R228 906 0 R /R229 907 0 R /R520 946 0 R /R220 908 0 R /R221 909 0 R /R222 910 0 R /R223 911 0 R /R224 912 0 R /R225 913 0 R /R226 914 0 R /R227 915 0 R /R1147 1190 0 R /R1146 1191 0 R /R1145 1192 0 R /R1144 1193 0 R /R1028 1148 0 R /R1029 1149 0 R /R1141 1196 0 R /R1140 1197 0 R /R1024 1198 0 R /R1025 1199 0 R /R1026 1200 0 R /R1027 1201 0 R /R1020 1202 0 R /R1021 1203 0 R /R1022 1099 0 R /R1023 1053 0 R /R314 921 0 R /R315 922 0 R /R316 923 0 R /R317 924 0 R /R310 925 0 R /R311 926 0 R /R312 927 0 R /R313 928 0 R /R233 838 0 R /R318 929 0 R /R319 930 0 R /R259 931 0 R /R258 932 0 R /R255 933 0 R /R254 934 0 R /R257 935 0 R /R256 936 0 R /R251 937 0 R /R250 938 0 R /R253 939 0 R /R252 940 0 R /R856 1212 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R18 15 0 R /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /R1201 1213 0 R /R1197 1218 0 R /R1195 1221 0 R /R1199 1226 0 R /F2 1229 0 R /F1 1230 0 R /R114 116 0 R /R659 1231 0 R /R648 420 0 R /R9 71 0 R /R642 417 0 R /R116 113 0 R /R657 1235 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /Group 424 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 1238 0 R 1239 0 R 1240 0 R 1241 0 R 1242 0 R 1243 0 R 1244 0 R 1245 0 R 1246 0 R 1247 0 R 1248 0 R 1249 0 R 1250 0 R 1251 0 R 1252 0 R 1253 0 R 1254 0 R ] /Type /Page >> endobj 7 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 1255 0 R /Resources << /ExtGState << /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /R1201 1213 0 R /R1197 1218 0 R /R9 71 0 R /F1 1256 0 R /R116 113 0 R /R1199 1226 0 R /R114 116 0 R /F2 1257 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 1258 0 R 1259 0 R 1260 0 R 1261 0 R 1262 0 R 1263 0 R ] >> endobj 8 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 1264 0 R /Resources << /ExtGState << /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /R1201 1213 0 R /R1197 1218 0 R /R1195 1221 0 R /F1 1265 0 R /R9 71 0 R /R116 113 0 R /R1199 1226 0 R /R114 116 0 R /F2 1266 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 1267 0 R 1268 0 R 1269 0 R 1270 0 R 1271 0 R 1272 0 R 1273 0 R 1274 0 R 1275 0 R 1276 0 R 1277 0 R 1278 0 R 1279 0 R 1280 0 R 1281 0 R 1282 0 R 1283 0 R 1284 0 R 1285 0 R ] >> endobj 9 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 1286 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R1252 1287 0 R /R1256 1288 0 R /R1255 1289 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /R1201 1213 0 R /R1197 1218 0 R /R1195 1221 0 R /F1 1290 0 R /R9 71 0 R /R116 113 0 R /R1199 1226 0 R /R114 116 0 R /R1253 1291 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R657 1235 0 R /F2 1294 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R /R15 80 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /Text /ImageC /ImageB /PDF /ImageI ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 1295 0 R 1296 0 R 1297 0 R 1298 0 R 1299 0 R 1300 0 R 1301 0 R 1302 0 R 1303 0 R ] >> endobj 10 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Contents 1304 0 R /Resources << /XObject << /R1280 1305 0 R /R1271 1317 0 R /R1274 1318 0 R /R1277 1308 0 R >> /ExtGState << /R18 15 0 R /R1270 1306 0 R /R1269 1307 0 R /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /R1195 1221 0 R /R1278 1309 0 R /R1275 1313 0 R /F1 1323 0 R /R1272 1319 0 R /R116 113 0 R /R9 71 0 R /F2 1324 0 R /R11 37 0 R /R66 86 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R32 41 0 R /R68 91 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /Group 45 0 R /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 1325 0 R 1326 0 R 1327 0 R 1328 0 R 1329 0 R 1330 0 R 1331 0 R ] /Type /Page >> endobj 11 0 obj << /Parent 1 0 R /Rotate 0 /Type /Page /Contents 1332 0 R /Resources << /ExtGState << /R8 64 0 R >> /Font << /F2 1333 0 R /R11 37 0 R /F1 1334 0 R /R15 80 0 R /R9 71 0 R >> /ProcSet [ /ImageC /Text /PDF /ImageI /ImageB ] >> /MediaBox [ 0 0 612 792 ] /Annots [ 1335 0 R 1336 0 R 1337 0 R 1338 0 R 1339 0 R 1340 0 R 1341 0 R 1342 0 R 1343 0 R 1344 0 R 1345 0 R 1346 0 R 1347 0 R 1348 0 R 1349 0 R 1350 0 R 1351 0 R 1352 0 R 1353 0 R 1354 0 R 1355 0 R 1356 0 R 1357 0 R 1358 0 R 1359 0 R 1360 0 R 1361 0 R 1362 0 R 1363 0 R 1364 0 R 1365 0 R 1366 0 R 1367 0 R 1368 0 R 1369 0 R 1370 0 R 1371 0 R 1372 0 R 1373 0 R 1374 0 R 1375 0 R 1376 0 R 1377 0 R 1378 0 R 1379 0 R 1380 0 R 1381 0 R 1382 0 R 1383 0 R 1384 0 R ] >> endobj 12 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 1 0 R >> endobj 13 0 obj << /Length 16105 >> stream q q q 0.10000 0 0 0.10000 0 0 cm /R8 gs 0 g q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R9 14.34620 Tf 1 0 0 1 183.37400 675.06700 Tm [ (Disco) 10.00310 (v) 9.99625 (ering) -249.99000 (Causal) -249.98800 (Signals) -250.00500 (in) -249.99300 (Images) ] TJ /R11 11.95520 Tf -69.58480 -37.85820 Td [ (Da) 19.98940 (vid) -250.00300 (Lopez\055P) 14.99130 (az) ] TJ -12.89920 -13.94690 Td [ (F) 15.01580 (acebook) -249.99200 (AI) -250.00300 (Research) ] TJ /R13 8.96640 Tf 27.45510 -13.94800 Td (dlp\100fb\056com) Tj /R11 11.95520 Tf 128.26100 27.89490 Td [ (Robert) -250 (Nishihara) ] TJ 9.77930 -13.94690 Td [ (UC) -249.99700 (Berk) 9.99010 (ele) 14.99130 (y) ] TJ /R13 8.96640 Tf -25.26130 -13.94800 Td (rkn\100eecs\056berkeley\056edu) Tj /R11 11.95520 Tf 156.84000 27.89490 Td [ (Soumith) -249.98900 (Chintala) ] TJ -12.33790 -13.94690 Td [ (F) 15.01580 (acebook) -249.99300 (AI) -250.00200 (Research) ] TJ /R13 8.96640 Tf 16.69490 -13.94800 Td (soumith\100fb\056com) Tj /R11 11.95520 Tf -227.77900 -19.92500 Td [ (Bernhard) -250.01000 (Sch) ] TJ 66.40510 0.05898 Td (\250) Tj -0.99883 -0.05898 Td [ (olk) 9.98397 (opf) ] TJ -83.73910 -13.94800 Td [ (MPI) -250.01400 (for) -249.99600 (Intelligent) -250.00800 (Systems) ] TJ /R13 8.96640 Tf 31.61480 -13.94800 Td (bs\100tue\056mpg\056de) Tj /R11 11.95520 Tf 166.78100 27.89610 Td (L) Tj 7.96875 0.05898 Td (\264) Tj -0.66367 -0.05898 Td [ (eon) -249.98700 (Bottou) ] TJ -31.60310 -13.94800 Td [ (F) 15.01580 (acebook) -249.99300 (AI) -250.00200 (Research) ] TJ /R13 8.96640 Tf 14.00510 -13.94800 Td (leon\100bottou\056org) Tj /R9 11.95520 Tf -198.31700 -41.04610 Td (Abstract) Tj /R15 9.96260 Tf 1.02000 0 0 1 62.06720 496.23900 Tm [ (This) -267.01800 (paper) -266.98900 (establishes) -266.01000 (the) -266.98600 (e) 19.00390 (xistence) -266 (of) -267 (observable) -267.00900 (foot\055) ] TJ -11.72070 -11.95590 Td [ (prints) -342.98500 (that) -342.99100 (r) 37.00180 (e) 14.00670 (veal) -343.00800 (the) -341.98300 (\223causal) -342.98800 (dispositions\224) -342.98400 (of) -342.99600 (the) -342.98400 (object) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (cate) 39.01270 (gories) -252.98200 (appearing) -253.01700 (in) -253.00800 (collections) -253.00900 (of) -254.00800 (ima) 10.01370 (g) 10.00170 (es\056) -327.99200 (W) 89.98640 (e) -253 (ac) 15.01340 (hie) 14.01150 (ve) ] TJ 0.99300 0 0 1 50.11210 460.37300 Tm [ (this) -252.01000 (goal) -253.01800 (in) -251.98100 (two) -252.99700 (steps\056) -313.99400 (F) 45.01480 (ir) 10 (st\054) -252.00900 (we) -252.98900 (tak) 11.01770 (e) -252.99900 (a) -252.00200 (learning) -252.98900 (appr) 46.01300 (oac) 15.01930 (h) -252.98900 (to) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 50.11210 448.41800 Tm [ (observational) -273.00800 (causal) -271.98700 (disco) 9.00585 (very) 53.99670 (\054) -279.01600 (and) -272.98400 (b) 19.99620 (uild) -272.99100 (a) -272.99600 <636c61737369026572> -273.01000 (that) ] TJ 1.00100 0 0 1 50.11210 436.46300 Tm [ (ac) 15.00580 (hie) 15.01620 (ves) -250.00200 (state\055of\055the\055art) -249.99500 (performance) -250.01900 (on) -251.01100 <026e64696e67> -249.99500 (the) -250.00700 (causal) ] TJ 0.99200 0 0 1 50.11210 424.50800 Tm [ (dir) 37.00990 (ection) -253.01200 (between) -253.99700 (pair) 11.00660 (s) -253.99900 (of) -253.01900 (r) 15.01100 (andom) -253.98200 (variables\054) -252.98200 (given) -254.02000 (samples) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 50.11210 412.55200 Tm [ (fr) 46.01510 (om) -208.01400 (their) -207.00900 (joint) -207.99600 (distrib) 19.99590 (ution\056) -300.00700 (Second\054) -216.98200 (we) -207.98800 (use) -207.99900 (our) -207.01300 (causal) -208.01900 (dir) 38.01640 (ec\055) ] TJ 1.01600 0 0 1 50.11210 400.59700 Tm [ (tion) -247.00300 <636c61737369026572> -247.01000 (to) -246.99500 (ef) 18.01030 (fectively) -246.99200 (distinguish) -246.98200 (between) -246.99900 (featur) 36.99250 (es) -246.98900 (of) ] TJ 0.99800 0 0 1 50.11210 388.64200 Tm [ (objects) -251.00700 (and) -251.99600 (featur) 37.00170 (es) -250.98700 (of) -252.00600 (their) -251.00200 (conte) 19.98760 (xts) -252.00900 (in) -250.98500 (collections) -251.99400 (of) -250.98500 (static) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 50.11210 376.68700 Tm [ (ima) 10.01430 (g) 10.00110 (es\056) -608.99000 (Our) -345.99800 (e) 20.00340 (xperiments) -347.00300 (demonstr) 15.00610 (ate) -346.98200 (the) -345.98200 (e) 19.00390 (xistence) -345.99400 (of) -346.99400 (a) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 50.11210 364.73200 Tm [ (r) 37.99820 (elation) -242.98400 (between) -242.98000 (the) -241.98100 (dir) 37.01610 (ection) -241.98600 (of) -242.99800 (causality) -243.01900 (and) -243.00700 (the) -241.98100 (dif) 18 (fer) 36.98860 (ence) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 50.11210 352.77700 Tm [ (between) -254.01400 (objects) -253.99000 (and) -252.99500 (their) -254.01000 (conte) 18.99190 (xts\054) -255.99200 (and) -253.99500 (by) -252.99300 (the) -253.99500 (same) -253.99700 (tok) 10.01370 (en\054) ] TJ 11.95590 TL T* [ (the) -317.99600 (e) 20.00280 (xistence) -318.01000 (of) -318.01100 (observable) -318.98000 (si) 0.98263 (gnals) -319.01400 (that) -318.00500 (r) 37.00120 (e) 14.00670 (veal) -317.98300 (the) -317.99800 (causal) ] TJ 1 0 0 1 50.11210 328.86600 Tm [ (dispositions) -250.00400 (of) -249.98500 (objects\056) ] TJ /R9 11.95520 Tf 36.76020 TL T* [ (1\056) -249.99000 (Intr) 18.01460 (oduction) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 1.00700 0 0 1 62.06720 272.87900 Tm [ (Imagine) -248.00700 (an) -248.00400 (image) -249.01000 (representi) 0.98193 (ng) -249.00800 (a) -247.98100 (bridge) -248.00700 (o) 15.00520 (v) 15.00520 (er) -248.00700 (a) -248.99200 (ri) 25.00460 (v) 15.00520 (er) 54.99790 (\056) -308 (On) ] TJ 1 0 0 1 50.11210 260.92400 Tm [ (top) -250.02000 (of) -249.99600 (the) -249.99000 (bridge\054) -250.02000 (a) -250.00200 (car) -250.01000 (is) -249.98400 (speeding) -250.01200 (through) -250.00700 (the) -249.99000 (right) -250.01500 (lane\056) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 62.06720 248.67100 Tm [ (Modern) -247.00200 (com) 0.98744 (pu) -0.98623 (t) 1 (er) -247.01200 (vision) -246.01600 (algorithms) -247.00300 (e) 15.00610 (xcel) -246.98400 (at) -246.00400 (answering) ] TJ 0.99200 0 0 1 50.11210 236.71500 Tm [ (questions) -252.00400 (about) -252.99800 (t) 1.00666 (he) -252.98600 (observ) 24.99480 (able) -252.00700 (properties) -251.99100 (of) -252.01100 (the) -253.00700 (scene\054) -252.01900 (such) ] TJ 1.00600 0 0 1 50.11210 224.76000 Tm [ (as) -248.01900 (such) -246.99400 (as) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 42.26050 0 Td [ (\223Is) -248 (ther) 36.98270 (e) -246.99300 (a) -248.01300 (car) -247.99400 (in) -247.01100 (this) -248.00800 (ima) 10.01420 (g) 10.00330 (e\077\224) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 122.72000 0 Td [ (\056) -308.01000 (This) -247.00100 (is) -247.98300 (achie) 25.01730 (v) 14.99090 (ed) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 50.11210 212.80500 Tm [ (by) -220.00400 (le) 25.99790 (v) 15.00660 (eraging) -219.99000 (correlations) -218.99200 (between) -219.98900 (pix) 14.98600 (els) -218.99100 (and) -219.98900 (image) -219.98100 (features) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 50.11210 200.85000 Tm [ (across) -246.98600 (lar) 16.99540 (ge) -246.99700 (datasets) -248.00100 (of) -246.98200 (images\056) -311.01200 (Ho) 25.00660 (we) 24.01560 (v) 14.99890 (er) 38.98330 (\054) -247.99500 (a) -247.00300 (more) -248 (nuanced) ] TJ 11.95510 TL T* [ (understanding) -380.01200 (of) -379.98500 (images) -378.99800 (ar) 16.99660 (guably) -378.98200 (requires) -380.01400 (the) -380.00200 (ability) -379.99700 (to) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf T* [ (r) 36.00240 (eason) -311.00300 (about) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 55.83600 0 Td [ (ho) 24 (w) -311.00800 (the) -312 (scene) -310.98800 (depicted) -311.99700 (in) -312.01300 (the) -311.00200 (image) -312.01800 (w) 10.00890 (ould) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 50.11210 164.98400 Tm [ (change) -220.99200 (in) -221.99300 (response) -220.98800 (to) -220.99300 (interv) 15.01980 (entions\056) -305.00400 (Since) -222.00900 (the) -221.01700 (list) -221.01700 (of) -222.00700 (possible) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 50.11210 153.02900 Tm [ (interv) 15.00910 (entions) -307.00600 (is) -307.00100 (long) -306.00400 (and) -306.99500 (comple) 15 (x\054) -321.98600 (we) -306.99400 (can\054) -321.99500 (as) -306.98700 (a) -307.00900 <02727374> -306.01200 (step\054) ] TJ 1 0 0 1 50.11210 141.07400 Tm [ (reason) -249.99300 (about) -250.01900 (the) -249.99000 (interv) 14.99500 (ention) -250.01200 (of) -249.99600 (remo) 14.98770 (ving) -250.01500 (an) -249.99700 (object\056) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 62.06720 128.82100 Tm [ (T) 77.98640 (o) -327.00500 (this) -326.98400 (end\054) -347.99000 (consider) -327.98900 (the) -326.99200 (tw) 10.00770 (o) -328.00500 (counterf) 9.98488 (actual) -327.00200 (questions) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf -15.52080 -11.95510 Td [ (\223What) -313.01000 (would) -314.01700 (the) -313 (scene) -313.98700 (look) -312.99300 (lik) 10.00770 (e) -314.00500 (if) -312.98200 (we) -312.98400 (wer) 36 (e) -313.00500 (to) -314.01200 (r) 36.00180 (emo) 9.98968 (ve) -312.99100 (the) ] TJ 3.80017 -11.95590 Td (car\077\224) Tj /R11 9.96260 Tf 28.20080 0 Td (and) Tj /R15 9.96260 Tf 17.28520 0 Td [ (\223What) -290.98400 (would) -290.99100 (the) -291.01100 (scene) -291 (look) -291.00500 (lik) 10.00650 (e) -291.01700 (if) -290.99300 (we) -290.99600 (wer) 36 (e) -291.01700 (to) ] TJ 0.99800 0 0 1 50.11210 92.95510 Tm [ (r) 36.98200 (emo) 9.98338 (ve) -250.00800 (the) -249.01000 (bridg) 9.98645 (e\077\224) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 85.52610 0 Td [ (On) -249.99300 (the) -249.01000 (one) -250.00700 (hand\054) -250.01000 (the) -249.99300 <02727374> -250.01700 (interv) 16.00730 (ention) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 50.11210 81 Tm [ (seems) -244.98700 (rather) -246.00100 (benign\056) -313.00500 (After) -245.99000 (remo) 16.00500 (ving) -245.99200 (the) -244.98200 (car) 40.00430 (\054) -246.99500 (we) -245.01000 (could) -246.01500 (ar) 17.98420 (gue) ] TJ ET Q q 3088.62000 3950.80000 2362.60000 1353.30000 re W n /R42 Do Q q 10 0 0 10 0 0 cm BT /R11 9.96260 Tf 0.99800 0 0 1 308.86200 376.74900 Tm [ (Figure) -248.98800 (1\072) -309.99500 (Our) -249.99500 (goal) -248.98600 (is) -250.01500 (to) -248.98100 (re) 24.99190 (v) 14.99320 (eal) -248.98600 (causal) -250.00200 (relationships) -248.98600 (between) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 308.86200 364.79400 Tm [ (pairs) -344.00700 (of) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 34.51860 0 Td [ (r) 36.00180 (eal) -343.98300 (entities) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 51.32160 0 Td [ (composing) -344.00300 (scenes) -343.98800 (in) -343.99800 (the) -343.98300 (w) 10.00890 (orld) -343.99800 (\050) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 133.24700 0 Td [ (e) 15.00610 (\056g) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 11.74940 0 Td (\056) Tj -232.13500 -11.95510 Td [ (\223the) -286 (presence) -285.98900 (of) -285 (cars) -285.99400 (cause) -286 (the) -286.01500 (presence) -284.99200 (of) -285.99600 (wheels\224\054) -296 (solid) ] TJ 1.29902 -11.95630 Td [ (blue) -316.99100 (arro) 23.98920 (w\051\056) -519.99400 (T) 77.98580 (o) -317.01000 (this) -316.98900 (end\054) -335.99700 (we) -316.98900 (apply) -316.98400 (a) -317.00300 (no) 14.00670 (v) 14.99650 (el) -317.00300 (observ) 23.99640 (ational) ] TJ 11.95470 TL T* [ (causal) -287.00300 (disco) 15.00130 (v) 14 (ery) -286.98400 (technique\054) -298.01400 (NCC\054) -286.99100 (to) -286.99100 (the) -287.01500 (joint) -286.98600 (distrib) 19.01360 (ution) ] TJ T* [ (of) -328.01400 (a) -326.99800 (pair) -328 (of) -328.01400 (related) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 79.94600 0 Td [ (pr) 44.00460 (oxy) -328.01600 (variables) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 65.85480 0 Td [ (that) -327.99200 (are) -326.99300 (computed) -327.99200 (by) ] TJ -145.80100 -11.95510 Td [ (applying) -274.99500 (CNNs) -275.00700 (to) -274.99500 (the) -274.98300 (image) -275.00200 (pix) 15.00610 (els\056) -392.99500 (Since) -275.00700 (these) -274.98300 (v) 23.99160 (ariables) ] TJ 0.98300 0 0 1 308.86200 293.06300 Tm [ (are) -253.98900 (e) 16.00970 (xpected) -254.00900 (to) -253.00500 (be) -254.01200 (highly) -253.01700 (correlated) -254.01700 (with) -253.02000 (the) -253.98700 (presence) -252.99500 (of) -254.00700 (the) ] TJ 1.00800 0 0 1 308.86200 281.10800 Tm [ (corresponding) -245.98600 (real) -247.01200 (entities\054) -246.01500 (the) -246.98300 (appearance) -245.98600 (of) -247.00200 (causation) -245.98100 (be\055) ] TJ 0.99200 0 0 1 308.86200 269.15200 Tm [ (tween) -252.01600 (the) -252.01900 (proxy) -251.99600 (v) 24.98500 (ariables) -251.98400 (\050dashed) -251.98400 (blue) -252.01400 (arro) 24.99480 (w\051) -251.98400 (suggests) -251.99400 (that) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 308.86200 257.19700 Tm [ (there) -264.98100 (is) -264.98600 (a) -263.99400 (causal) -265.01500 (link) -264.99600 (between) -265.01700 (the) -264.98800 (real) -264.98800 (w) 10.00890 (orld) -265.00300 (entities) -263.99400 (them\055) ] TJ 1 0 0 1 308.86200 245.24200 Tm [ (selv) 14.99260 (es) -249.01500 (\050) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 29.99300 0 Td [ (e) 15.01220 (\056g) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 11.74610 0 Td [ (\056) -309.00500 (the) -249.01000 (appearance) -248.99300 (of) -247.99800 (causation) -248.99300 (between) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 154.05300 0 Td [ (scor) 36.98890 (e\050car\051) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 1.02000 0 0 1 308.86200 233.28700 Tm (and) Tj /R15 9.96260 Tf 16.89410 0 Td [ (scor) 36.00660 (e\050wheel\051) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 53.60290 0 Td [ (suggests) -251.99100 (that) -251.99600 (the) -250.99600 (presence) -252.01000 (of) -252.01500 (cars) -252.01000 (causes) ] TJ 1 0 0 1 308.86200 221.33200 Tm [ (the) -249.99000 (presence) -250.00200 (of) -249.99500 (wheels) -249.98500 (in) -249.98500 (the) -249.98800 (real) -250.00200 (w) 10.00320 (orld\056\051) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 308.86200 176.64100 Tm [ (that) -316.99800 (the) -315.99900 (rest) -316.99100 (of) -315.98200 (the) -316.99800 (scene) -316.98400 (depicted) -315.99400 (in) -317.01300 (the) -315.99900 (image) -317.01700 (\050the) -317.00800 (ri) 25.01500 (v) 14.99650 (er) 38.98330 (\054) ] TJ 1.01800 0 0 1 308.86200 164.68600 Tm [ (the) -244.99200 (bridge\051) -243.99300 (w) 9.99486 (ould) -245.00700 (remain) -244.99500 (i) 0.99178 (n) 39.00210 (v) 23.98090 (ariant\056) -303.99100 (On) -243.98800 (the) -244.99000 (other) -245.01400 (hand\054) -244.01700 (the) ] TJ 1.02000 0 0 1 308.86200 152.73100 Tm [ (second) -293 (interv) 14.00910 (ention) -292.99700 (seems) -292.99200 (more) -294.01100 (se) 24.98620 (v) 13.99710 (ere\056) -448.01700 (If) -294.01100 (the) -293.01100 (bridge) -294.00600 (had) ] TJ T* [ (been) -309.01900 (remo) 15.00850 (v) 14 (ed) -309 (from) -308.98800 (the) -309.00300 (scene\054) -325.99800 (it) -308.98300 (w) 10.00890 (ould\054) -325.00800 (in) -309.01700 (general\054) -324.98400 (mak) 8.98543 (e) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 308.86200 128.82100 Tm [ (little) -250.00600 (sense) -249.00300 (to) -250 (observ) 14.98100 (e) -249 (the) -249.98300 (car) -248.98300 <036f6174696e67> -250.01300 (weightlessly) -249.98300 (abo) 15.98870 (v) 15.00850 (e) -250.00300 (the) ] TJ T* [ (ri) 25.98360 (v) 15.00600 (er) 55.99310 (\056) -301.00800 (Thus\054) -218.01600 (we) -209.00100 (understand) -208.99400 (that) -208.99900 (t) 1.01524 (he) -208.98900 (presence) -208.98400 (of) -209.00400 (the) -209.01400 (bridge) -209.00400 (has) ] TJ 1.01700 0 0 1 308.86200 104.91000 Tm (an) Tj /R15 9.96260 Tf 11.85360 0 Td [ (ef) 18.00940 (fect) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 24.02360 0 Td [ (on) -246.01900 (the) -246.01100 (presence) -244.99000 (of) -246.00200 (the) -246.01100 (car) 54.01860 (\056) -304.97900 (Reasoning) -244.99000 (about) -246.01600 (these) ] TJ 1.01000 0 0 1 308.86200 92.95510 Tm [ (and) -247 (similar) -247.00500 (counterf) 10.01580 (actuals) -246.99300 (allo) 25 (ws) -246.99300 (to) -246.98800 (be) 15.01400 (gin) -247.00300 (asking) ] TJ /R15 9.96260 Tf 201.56300 0 Td [ (\223Why) -246.99800 (is) ] TJ 0.98000 0 0 1 308.86200 81 Tm [ (ther) 37.99390 (e) -248 (a) -248.01500 (car) -248.00800 (in) -248 (this) -247.99500 (ima) 11.01260 (g) 10.00480 (e\077\224) ] TJ /R11 9.96260 Tf 110.64500 0 Td [ (This) -247.99300 (question) -248.00800 (is) -248.01300 (of) -247.01300 (course) -247.98800 (poorly) ] TJ 1 0 0 1 295.12100 51.11210 Tm (1) Tj ET Q Q Q q q 1 1 1 rg /a0 gs 48.40600 786.42200 515.18800 -52.69900 re f q /s5 gs /x6 Do Q q /s7 gs /x8 Do Q q /s9 gs /x10 Do Q q /s11 gs /x12 Do Q Q Q Q q 1 0 0 1 0 0 cm BT /F1 12 Tf 14.40000 TL ET 1 1 1 rg n 270 47 72 14 re f* 0.50000 0.50000 0.50000 rg BT /F2 9 Tf 10.80000 TL ET BT 1 0 0 1 297 50 Tm (6979) Tj T* ET Q endstream endobj 14 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /BBox [ 5009.35000 4903.40000 5055.69000 4949.74000 ] /Resources << /ExtGState << /R18 15 0 R >> >> /Length 167 /Group 16 0 R /Type /XObject /FormType 1 /Matrix [ 1 0 0 1 0 0 ] /Subtype /Form >> stream xݏ1DsU >(f8Ǎ@ɻ+f/Vʊ68SEQ̍L~k*%EJT)~xleʽBt ITE$hcW"#\Fɴd|~Sv-hT endstream endobj 15 0 obj << /Type /ExtGState /BM /Normal >> endobj 16 0 obj << /S /Transparency /Type /Group /K true /I true >> endobj 17 0 obj << /Filter /FlateDecode /BBox [ 3088.62000 3950.80000 5451.22000 5304.10000 ] /Resources << /ExtGState << /R18 15 0 R >> /XObject << /R41 18 0 R /R40 19 0 R /R21 20 0 R /R19 21 0 R /R23 22 0 R /R22 23 0 R /R26 24 0 R /R29 25 0 R /R28 26 0 R /R27 27 0 R /R38 28 0 R /R39 29 0 R /R36 30 0 R /R37 31 0 R /R34 32 0 R /R35 33 0 R /R25 34 0 R /R24 35 0 R /R30 36 0 R /R31 14 0 R >> /Font << /R11 37 0 R /R32 41 0 R >> >> /Length 2285 /Group 45 0 R /Type /XObject /FormType 1 /Matrix [ 1 0 0 1 0 0 ] /Subtype /Form >> stream xYn7߯襴0d 2;'fdṾqlHs-Yq00VSUu8?D${f%X6#^lo?g~|8xpC uv0Ud6 .m7۫OӇ\ru>;_}溷|_o^~sxu*/p1o"(«I%_1(}R}E{p{ʋ]bxX
+-s>(oαQ;{wp)/{/8dF}Ë.ѽl(1Z:)6G+ӫ/Nw7/V"oys@; aT
K
SO%EĜ1.ƒ;x
9|gy_XYq3Qq^#ز;!\45H_F*E|F'{(ȐDb:VK/t6D+n(|{|j|ܬ&0Q:aàZW3ijs-wߞZ#2 w\Tt^Fۥh
7+3&:mҙ-^YV$bZ|GcogX$e(`ZmZ ^&"rk炽AMkmǾQ
{DV-oQ ۜ*49T}`&쀡V<\hZ-(X2VêHV lfs%c**Dgjق:v6Lhh@ܷ
\ do)Ů=-;vWд_3Pu
,@ʷz +lQUI{\m?$_@. ޭ@ F <4#eW۩㡁0L s?$ =s}nO7[&Z۵LNl1JW.*p>qA}ÙLhטY
[cE"^WtF|S^g1O8萞{WwcG(8K;gZZ"Ǩ7ΔlZ.:ڙ%+K0ej)}]Ws TFlƐ5)P@1(xHPL.4UTCu-VC/y]%p0L]y)QxY~/ED1,R[l͇u5uyĮXc8B\1ԏ>켟M{4-3#><ט)1yZr"}gͰKI9%H\yD&1`-@:SF ˿,6%g/g,&">Vx?T=]q!fd[R8Fqp0V
WI{$a93Eɖ<X}q!_ڔ-"Nvr"804 ,xq֝[0Nu
x~%PP;&=G;w#Ѯ];XU`yPKr
t)䰰GISvn)dy
\'rSyů\:ky
͡Q:j08ϺTv 88@ C&ͅרIW۶ L T;rSـZ+rYbb[n:F1eL.bxR^@ iji4-;ѕw` 24N( _Lz^ऄ'ap\<
h>Z3ż4]r-`KEMI?rBHjM3'KG}h*2IhwG(uI{
ʬjWՅ7];tK^tXsIFVM(3h'U Bl`Sl.윟;Rª$-KPkw